Mont Royal is very different. The trees are mostly small, thin and now bare, many of them replanted after the ice storm of a decade or so. Deciduous, they were all moving in different directions, crackling and wheezing like the old men who gather around the punching bag at the Y mid afternoon. It wasn't that windy on the mountain, but it was cold, which seems to breed a different kind of noise. Imagine walking on Styrofoam. Now imagine doing that in a freezer. So, to hear you have to stop. Try to balance yourself in the drifts to really listen.
One wonders, one wonders in these moments who is in charge of the exchange. What are the terms? What did the woodpecker want? Was I on his turf (clearly), was I food (possibly). I was thinking about this when swoop, three chickadees descended, again, closer than I've ever had a chickadee fly, and cheerful as they usually are, flashing me their bellies, snapping from branch to branch like elastic bands it was still a little disconcerting so many at once. Then a nuthatch, high in a bare birch at first, but then swoop, swoop, the upside down zips. I moved a little at this point, down a smaller path and into a stand of deciduous, and as I did, so did my entourage, the nuthatch at one point hanging directly over my head. Evidence below, only the tail feathers to show for it.
But I am deeply skeptical about the reportage of such encounters. The specialness of the reporter--in this case myself--in the center of the poem's world. I am also worried about the use of animals in literature just as I worry about the Polar Bears and Beavers, the Marmots and Iguanas, the parade of animals appearing in all manner of advertising, staring out at us from the floating nether worlds they are often photographed in, as if they had no firm ground to stand on as they ply us with products, services, offers of exotic, distant lands. I consider the deer showing up in Mary Oliver's poems. I consider Don McKay's Chickadee Encounters, and report on Ravens in Vis-a-Vis, I think of Lilburn lying down in the long, waves of Saskatchewan, and imagine Jan Zwicky somewhere thinking about this. Oddly enough I don't imagine Zwicky "in nature." No, I imagine Anne Carson in a frozen expanse, fuming as she walks, much easier than I imagine Zwicky with mud on her boots. But I digress. What I'm wondering is how to get at what this moment means to us without getting sentimental? What is the ethical way to deal with these encounters? What are we trying to represent? One part of me thinks that human sight is deadly: if we have seen something, it's over.
Friday it was cold in Montreal. Not as cold as it can get. This was a fleece-down-vest-under-gortex-wrapped-in-wool-and-more-fleece-on-top kind of day as opposed to a down-vest-parka-every-inch-wrapped sort of day. Still, it was the kind of cold that makes the snow seem a bit like sawdust from the finest sandpaper, and the sky so clear it's hard to imagine it won't at any minute, crack. I did think, momentarily, that the trees were shivering, trying to stay warm.
8 comments:
What wonderful encounters with birds and trees. I hear you on the skepticism of unity with nature poems. The majority of time skipped over. Rare presented as majority. Rather like news hour.
Skepticism of unity, that certainly gets at it.
Thanks for the visit.
I laughed aloud at your spot-on assessment of the impossibility of imagining Zwicky existing in nature...or for that matter, outside the confines of a book. Talk about someone who appears only in the floating nether worlds! I love Lyric Philosophy but who can imagine its author stepping in a cow plop?
Glad your wild bird encounter didn't turn all Hitchcock...which would be just a different kind of anthropocentric nature poem, I guess.
Yes, I appreciate Jan Zwicky as well, but I'm glad you know what I mean.
Hm. I wonder if the Downy expected something from you? Apparently, some learn the upside of being hand fed. While I haven't yet had a run-in with an aggressive or demanding woodpecker, I do know from my stays at St. Peter's Abbey what it's like to be harassed by relentless chickadees and nuthatches who are used to being hand fed. And the birds there have become picky eaters. Sunflower seeds are not good enough for them. They expect peanuts.
As for the matter of ethics, well, that's a whole other thing.
Yes, as I said, I did wonder if I represented food. Perhaps I look like a well-rotted birch? About to fall over and ripe with bugs?
I made a kind of response to your article here... & Thank you for this blog.
Ah Michael, the broken wing is indeed a difficult encounter. Thank you for your post, and here's to ongoing discussions.
Post a Comment